Payroll and People Paying a team without creating a liability.

Payroll and People

PERSONAL LIABILITY

The Trust Fund Recovery Penalty, and Who It Reaches

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

The unpaid payroll tax that follows an owner home is the part withheld from workers, and no LLC has ever stopped section 6672 from reaching it.

You formed the LLC so the business debts would stay with the business. Then a payroll deposit got skipped, then a second one, and now a revenue officer wants an interview with you personally. The entity is supposed to prevent exactly that. It does not prevent this.

Internal Revenue Code section 6672 reaches through the entity and assesses unpaid tax against individuals. It is called the trust fund recovery penalty, and the word doing the work is trust. Money withheld from your employees' checks was never company money. Section 7501 turns it into a special fund held in trust for the United States the moment it leaves their pay, so failing to hand it over reads as a breach of trust rather than an unpaid bill.

What the penalty actually covers

Not every dollar of a missed payroll deposit follows you home. The trust fund portion is the part you took out of your employees' pay:

Your matching employer share of Social Security and Medicare sits outside it. FUTA sits outside it. So do the interest and penalties that accrue on the underlying balance. All of that stays with the business, which is cold comfort when the business has nothing left in it.

Take a pay run of 40,000 dollars in gross wages, and say 5,000 dollars of federal income tax came out under the W-4s on file. Employee FICA at 7.65 percent adds 3,060. The full federal deposit for that run would be 11,120, since your employer match contributes another 3,060. Skip the deposit and the business owes 11,120. The figure that can be assessed against you as a person is 8,060, because that is the part that belonged to the people who worked for you.

Two elements, both wider than owners expect

An assessment requires a responsible person who acted willfully. Both words are terms of art, and both get read broadly.

Responsible person describes a function, never a job title. Courts and the IRS look at who carried the duty and the authority to see the tax paid. The evidence tends to include:

Notice how little of that concerns ownership. A bookkeeper with signature authority who chose the payment order can be a responsible person. So can a controller, an office manager, a corporate officer who never set foot in the building, a board member who approved payment priorities, or an outside party who took control of disbursements. Titles are evidence. Titles are not the test.

More than one person can be responsible for the same quarter, and each is liable for the entire amount rather than a slice of it. The IRS can assess several people at once and pursue every one of them. It collects the total only once, but nobody gets excused by pointing across the table.

Willful does not mean malicious. It means you knew, or plainly should have known, that the withheld tax went unpaid, and you used available funds on something else anyway. Paying a supplier to keep the doors open while the deposit sits undone is the textbook version of it. Reckless disregard of an obvious risk counts as well. So does learning after the fact: discover an old unpaid liability, then come into unencumbered funds and spend them elsewhere, and you can become willful for a period you were not even there for.

How it arrives

This almost never starts with a letter out of nowhere. A revenue officer working the business will interview people using Form 4180, a structured questionnaire about authority and knowledge. Answer it carelessly and you have built the government's file for them. Skip it and the officer proceeds on what everyone else said about you.

Letter 1153 comes next, with Form 2751 attached, proposing the assessment and naming the number. You have 60 days from the date on that letter to protest and take it to Appeals. Let the window close and the penalty is assessed against you individually, at which point ordinary collection starts: a federal tax lien filed publicly under your own name, levies on personal bank accounts, wage garnishment.

It also outlives the exits people reach for. Dissolve the company and the assessment stands. Put the company into bankruptcy and the assessment stands. Personal bankruptcy generally will not discharge it either, because trust fund taxes sit in a priority category the discharge does not touch.

The move most owners never make

When a business with a payroll tax balance makes a voluntary payment, it can tell the IRS where to apply it. Put the designation on the payment and in a short cover letter: this payment applies to the trust fund portion of the Form 941 liability for the quarter ending on such and such a date. Undesignated payments get applied in the government's best interest, which in practice means the parts that do not follow anybody home get retired first, leaving the piece attached to you sitting there longest.

Levies and seizures cannot be designated, because those are not your payments. This is a tool that exists only while you are still the one deciding what to pay.

Where a payroll provider fits, and where it does not

Handing payroll to an outside firm does not hand over the liability. If a provider debits your account for the tax and never remits it, the employer stays liable for the tax, and the individuals behind the employer stay exposed under 6672 for the withheld part.

Four habits close most of that risk. Enroll in the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System under your own credentials and confirm every cycle that the deposits actually posted. Keep the IRS address of record as your address, so notices land on your desk rather than in a service bureau's mailroom. Read the Form 941 before it is filed instead of after a notice shows up. And reconcile the four quarterly returns against the annual W-3 totals before January closes.

What prevention looks like

There is no clever structure for this one. Prevention is mechanical. The withheld money is not operating cash, so do not leave it sitting in the operating account where it will get spent by accident on a slow Thursday. Move it out on the day of the run, or run a deposit schedule tight enough that there is never anything there to spend.

If you are already behind, the worst option available is to go quiet and keep running payroll the same way. Every additional quarter adds a fresh assessable period and another set of facts establishing that you knew. Owners who climb out of this generally stop the bleeding first and deal with the arrears second, in that order, even though the arrears are the part keeping them awake.

The entity you formed does real work. It stands between your house and a supplier's unpaid invoice, a slip and fall claim, a contract that went bad. It has never once stood between anyone and the money they took out of their own employees' checks and spent.

Common questions

can the IRS come after me personally for unpaid payroll taxes

Yes, through the trust fund recovery penalty in section 6672, which assesses the withheld portion against individuals no matter how the business is organized. It reaches anyone who had the duty and the authority to see the tax paid and who used available money on something else instead. An LLC or a corporation does not block it.

does the trust fund penalty include the employer share of payroll taxes

No. It covers what you took out of your workers' pay, meaning federal income tax plus the employee half of Social Security and Medicare. Your matching employer share stays with the business, along with FUTA and any interest or penalties that built up on the balance.

what is Letter 1153 from the IRS

It is the notice proposing a trust fund recovery penalty against you as an individual, and it arrives with Form 2751 showing the amount. You have 60 days from the date on that letter to file a protest and take the question to the Appeals office. Letting the window close means the penalty gets assessed, after which collection runs against your personal assets.

More on this