Payroll and People Paying a team without creating a liability.

Payroll and People

WORKERS COMP

Workers Compensation When You Have a Small Team

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

Your state decides whether you need coverage at all, and the class codes, the mod and the year end audit decide what that coverage actually costs.

Two people on the payroll, and a letter from the state asking about workers compensation coverage. The honest answer to whether you need it is that your state decides, and in plenty of states the answer is yes from the first employee onward.

There is no federal workers compensation program for ordinary private employers. Each state runs its own, sets its own threshold for when coverage becomes mandatory, decides who counts toward that threshold, and writes its own penalties for going without. Some start at one employee. Others start higher. Agriculture, domestic work and construction are frequently pulled out of the general rule, and construction almost always gets pulled toward stricter coverage rather than looser.

What you are actually buying

Workers compensation is no fault insurance. An injured employee gets medical treatment and a portion of lost wages without proving anybody did anything wrong. In return, the exclusive remedy rule generally bars that employee from suing you in court over the injury. That trade is the whole design of the system, and it is the half owners forget when they look at a premium quote and decide to go without.

Going without removes both halves. States impose their own penalties, which can run to daily fines, stop work orders that shut the job down, and personal liability for officers. Separately, and usually worse, you lose the exclusive remedy defense. An injured worker can sue you directly, with pain and suffering on the table and your own assets standing behind it. Many states also run a fund that pays the claim first and then comes after the uninsured employer for every dollar of it.

Who counts is broader than your payroll list

Counting employees for the threshold is not the same as counting W-2s. Depending on the state, the count can pull in part time workers, seasonal hires, family members drawing a wage, and corporate officers on salary. Leased and temporary staff may count under the staffing firm's arrangement instead of yours, which is a question to ask rather than assume.

The one that catches owners is subcontractors. In most states an uninsured subcontractor doing work for you is treated as your employee for compensation purposes. You never hired him, you never put him on payroll, and at the end of the policy year everything you paid him surfaces in your audit as payroll. The defense is a certificate of insurance from every sub, obtained before the work begins, with policy dates that actually span the period he was on site. A certificate that expired in March doesn't do a thing for an injury in June.

How the premium is built

The formula is simpler than the invoice makes it look.

Start with payroll, which the policy calls remuneration and defines in its own way. Split it by class code, which describes what the business does rather than what any one person's title says. Each class code carries a rate expressed in dollars per 100 dollars of payroll. Multiply payroll divided by 100 by that rate and you have manual premium.

Then apply your experience modification factor, assuming your payroll is large enough to qualify for one. The mod compares your own loss history against what a business of your size and class is expected to produce. Below 1.00 you pay less than the class average. Above 1.00 you pay more.

Take a small contractor with 300,000 dollars of annual payroll, all of it in a class rated at 6 dollars per 100 dollars of payroll. Manual premium is 300,000 divided by 100, times 6, which comes to 18,000. Carry a mod of 1.20 and it becomes 21,600. Carry a mod of 0.85 and it becomes 15,300. Same payroll, same work, a gap of 6,300 dollars driven by nothing but claim history.

After the mod come the additions: an expense constant, state assessments, catastrophe loads, plus any scheduled credit or debit the underwriter is permitted to apply in that state.

Two of those inputs repay a look. Class codes get assigned once and then never revisited, so a business whose operations drifted over five years is often paying a rate for work it stopped doing. Clerical staff and outside sales people can frequently be separated into much cheaper codes, but only where your payroll records genuinely segregate the duties. A bookkeeper who also drives the truck on Fridays does not qualify.

The mod is a three year memory

Your experience modification is calculated by a rating bureau from the data your carrier reports. In most states that is the National Council on Compensation Insurance. Several states run their own bureau instead. Either way the calculation uses a fixed window, typically three policy years ending about a year before the rating date, which means a bad year keeps charging you long after it stops feeling recent. A good year takes exactly as long to arrive.

The formula does not treat all losses alike. The first slice of each claim, called the primary loss, is weighted far more heavily than the amount above it. So a pattern of small claims raises a mod more than one large claim of the same total value. Frequency is the thing being priced.

That points straight at where an owner still has control after somebody gets hurt. Report the injury immediately. Have a relationship with a treating provider before you need one. And bring the employee back on modified duty the moment a doctor clears it, because paid lost time is what turns a manageable medical claim into an expensive indemnity claim that sits in your mod for years.

The audit is the real invoice

The premium you paid at the start of the year was an estimate built on estimated payroll. At the end of the term the carrier audits what actually happened: real payroll, real class assignments, real payments to subs. Then it bills or refunds the difference.

Prepare for it the way you would prepare for a tax examination. Keep payroll records that break down by class code. Keep certificates for every sub, filed by name and by date. Keep overtime separated, because a number of states let you exclude the premium portion of overtime pay from the payroll base, and nobody is going to do that for you when your records show one lump figure.

Owners sometimes try to solve the premium by moving people to 1099 status. That works right up until the auditor applies the state's own test, reclassifies the workers, and bills the payroll anyway. It then tends to hand the same facts to a second agency with a different penalty schedule.

What it is not

Workers compensation covers workplace injury and nothing wider. It is not general liability, which responds when your operations injure somebody who does not work for you. It is not disability coverage, which handles the off the job injury that keeps somebody home. A handful of workforces also sit outside the state systems entirely, including longshore and harbor workers, railroad employees and federal civilian employees, each covered by a separate federal scheme.

If your state threshold genuinely lets you skip coverage and you decide to skip it, price that decision honestly before you sign off on it. You are not saving a premium. You are taking an uninsured retention on a risk you cannot size, and giving up the one defense that would have kept the whole question out of a courtroom.

Common questions

do I need workers comp insurance if I only have one employee

That depends on your state, and several of them require coverage from the first employee with no small employer exemption at all. Others set a threshold of a few workers, and many carve construction out for stricter treatment. Look up the rule for your state and your industry rather than the general rule, because the industry carve outs are where the surprises live.

what is an experience modification factor and how is it calculated

It is a multiplier applied to your manual premium that compares your own claim history against what a business of your class and size is expected to produce. A rating bureau calculates it from payroll and loss data over a fixed window, usually three policy years ending about a year before the rating date. The formula weights the first slice of each claim most heavily, so a run of small claims can push it higher than one large one.

will my workers comp audit count subcontractors as employees

It will if you cannot produce a certificate of insurance showing the subcontractor carried his own coverage for the dates he worked. Most states treat an uninsured sub as your employee for compensation purposes, and the auditor adds what you paid him to your payroll base. Collect the certificate before work starts and check that the policy dates span the whole job.

More on this