Payroll and People Paying a team without creating a liability.

Payroll and People

S CORPORATION

Reasonable Compensation for an S Corporation Owner

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

No percentage in the law sets an S corporation owner's salary, so the number has to be built from what the work you actually do would cost to replace.

How much do you have to pay yourself out of the S corporation? There is no percentage in the law. The standard is what it would cost to hire somebody else to do the work you are actually doing, and your number has to survive a stranger reading the file.

The question exists because of arithmetic. Wages carry Social Security and Medicare tax, 7.65 percent from the employee and 7.65 percent from the company, 15.3 percent all in. Distributions to a shareholder carry none of it. Set the salary at zero, run everything out as distribution, and the payroll tax vanishes. The IRS noticed this a very long time ago. Revenue Ruling 74-44 set out the position still in use: where a shareholder performs services and takes distributions in place of wages, those distributions get recharacterized as wages, with tax and penalties following.

There is no safe percentage

You will hear a sixty forty split offered as the rule, or fifty fifty. Neither appears in the Internal Revenue Code, in the regulations, or in published IRS guidance. They are conventions that circulated among preparers until they hardened into folklore. A split that happens to produce a defensible salary for one business will produce an indefensible one for the shop next door with identical revenue and a different labor profile.

What the courts actually do is weigh facts. The factors come out of a long line of compensation cases and out of the agency's own material, and they read best as a list of what your file should be able to answer:

One frame from the case law is worth carrying around. It gets called the independent investor test, and it asks whether an outsider who put money into this company would be satisfied with the return left over after the owner is paid a market salary. Where the answer is clearly yes, the distributions look like a return on invested capital. Where the profit exists because the owner works sixty hours a week for almost nothing, they look like wages wearing a different label.

Three ways to arrive at a number

The cost approach, sometimes called the many hats method, suits most small operating companies. You break the owner's working time into the jobs actually being performed, price each job at what that work pays in your own labor market, and weight by hours. It produces a figure you can explain to an examiner in one sentence.

The market approach looks for salary data matched to the position, the industry, the region and the size of the company, then uses it directly. It works cleanly where the owner performs one recognizable job, like a practice owner who is also the practitioner.

The income approach comes at it from the return side, using the independent investor logic to work out how much profit ought to remain after compensation. It fits businesses with real capital behind them, or earnings well beyond what one person's labor explains.

Take an S corporation with 200,000 dollars of profit before any owner compensation, run by a single shareholder working in it full time. Under the cost approach you break the job into what replacing it would cost:

Price each role at local market pay, weight by hours, and suppose the total lands at 95,000 dollars. Run that through payroll as W-2 wages. Employer side FICA on it is 7.65 percent, or 7,267.50. The remaining 97,732.50 can flow out as distribution without payroll tax on it.

Now compare a 30,000 dollar salary on identical facts. You save payroll tax on the 65,000 dollar gap in the current year. Both halves of FICA on that gap come to 9,945 dollars, which is what sits exposed if an examiner later recharacterizes it, before the failure to deposit penalty, the failure to file penalty and the interest running while the question stays open.

The number does more than set your tax

A low salary reaches into places owners rarely think about when they set it.

Retirement contributions for a shareholder employee are calculated on W-2 wages. A 30,000 dollar salary caps what you can defer and caps any employer contribution on top of it, which in a good year costs more than the payroll tax it avoided.

Health insurance for a shareholder who owns more than 2 percent of the company has to run through the W-2 to stay deductible. The premiums go into Box 1 wages, stay out of Social Security and Medicare wages, and are then deducted on the personal return. Skip the W-2 step and the deduction is at risk.

The qualified business income deduction under section 199A pulls in both directions here, which is why blanket advice fails. Wages you pay yourself reduce the qualified business income the deduction is computed on. At higher income levels, though, the deduction is limited by reference to the W-2 wages the business paid, so a salary set too low can shrink the very deduction it was meant to protect. Where you land depends on your income level, and it moves as the business grows.

And Social Security keeps its own score. Benefits are figured from your lifetime earnings record, and years of token W-2 wages are years of token contribution to it. Somebody who pays themselves almost nothing for fifteen years is trading a present day tax saving for a permanently smaller benefit later.

Documenting it so it holds

The salary is a decision. Treat it like one.

Write a compensation policy stating how the figure was determined and what data it rests on. Approve it in the minutes each year, ahead of the year it covers rather than after. Keep a written description of what the shareholder actually does, with an honest estimate of hours. Keep whatever comparable pay data you used, along with the date you pulled it. A justification assembled during an examination reads exactly like a justification assembled during an examination.

Run the money as payroll. Regular pay dates, withholding, deposits on schedule, a W-2 at year end. A single December entry reclassifying distributions into wages beats doing nothing and still falls short of doing it right, because it makes the deposit schedule impossible to have met.

Two flows out of the company legitimately are not wages, and both repay keeping clean. Expense reimbursements under a written accountable plan are not compensation, so long as there is substantiation and excess advances come back. A real loan to the shareholder is not compensation, so long as there is a note, a stated rate, a repayment schedule and actual repayments hitting the account. Each one turns into wages the moment the paperwork stops matching the behavior.

If the company had a loss year and the shareholder worked in it anyway, the question does not disappear, though the analysis shifts. You can't pay wages the business cannot fund. What you can do is document the year, the services performed, and why no salary was paid, so the file answers the question before anybody asks it.

The cheap version of this is the one you set on purpose, with a paragraph explaining why, before a return goes out the door. Everything after that is argument.

Common questions

how much salary do I have to pay myself from my S corp

There is no percentage in the law, so the answer is whatever it would cost to hire somebody to do the work you actually do. Most small companies get there by pricing the roles the owner fills at local market pay and weighting them by hours. Whichever method you use, the file has to show the reasoning and the data underneath it.

is the 60/40 rule for S corporation salary real

No. The sixty forty split and the fifty fifty split are preparer conventions, and neither appears in the Internal Revenue Code, the regulations or published IRS guidance. A percentage that produces a defensible wage for one business produces an indefensible one for the shop next door with the same revenue and different work.

what happens if the IRS says my S corp salary was too low

The examiner recharacterizes distributions as wages, which brings employment tax on the reclassified amount plus penalties for late deposits and late returns, with interest running on top. The corporation does get a deduction for the additional wages, so the real cost is the employment tax and the penalties rather than income tax. A compensation study written at the time, and minutes approving it, are what usually keep the conversation short.

More on this