Payroll and People Paying a team without creating a liability.

Payroll and People

PAYROLL TAX

Payroll Taxes: Who Owes What, and On What Schedule

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

Every pay run creates two piles of tax, one withheld from your people and one owed out of your own funds, on deposit calendars you do not get to pick.

Payroll went out Friday. The money left the account, everyone got paid, and now there is another number due Wednesday that nobody warned you about. That number is the deposit, and it is a separate obligation from the wages.

Here is the shape of it. Every pay run creates two piles of tax. One pile you withheld from the employee, which was their money and is now sitting in your account on the government's behalf. The other pile you owe on top of wages, out of your own funds. Both piles usually travel on the same deposit, which is why owners lump them together and then underfund the bank account. They are not the same money, and missing them does not carry the same consequence.

The two piles, line by line

Withheld from the employee's gross pay:

Owed by you, on top of gross wages:

The Social Security wage base moves every year. It is indexed and announced in the autumn for the year ahead, so never carry last year's figure forward in a spreadsheet. Once an employee's wages with you cross that base, the 6.2 percent stops on both sides for the rest of the calendar year. Medicare keeps running to the last dollar.

One wrinkle. The wage base is per employer, not per person. Somebody who changes jobs in July starts a fresh base with the new employer, and both employers pay their full share. The worker recovers the excess withholding on a personal return. You recover nothing. And that is the correct result, not an error to chase.

FUTA and state unemployment are two halves of one machine

FUTA is imposed at 6.0 percent on the first 7,000 dollars of each worker's wages for the year. Against that sits a credit of up to 5.4 percent for state unemployment tax paid on time, which leaves 0.6 percent in an ordinary year in an ordinary state. The credit is the whole reason FUTA looks small.

There are two ways to lose it. Pay your state unemployment tax late and the credit shrinks on those wages. Operate in a state that borrowed from the federal unemployment account and has not repaid it, and every employer in that state takes a credit reduction, applied on the annual return, against wages you already paid months earlier.

State unemployment is where the real variance lives. Your state sets its own wage base, which may sit far above the federal 7,000 or close to it. Your rate is experience rated, meaning it moves with your own claim history. A new business pays a standard starting rate for a few years and then gets priced on its own record. Every claim paid out of your account becomes a line in that record, which is the unglamorous reason to answer separation notices on time instead of letting them sit.

The schedule comes from a lookback, not from your size today

Federal deposits run on one of two calendars, and you don't pick.

The IRS looks at a fixed window: the four quarters ending June 30 of the prior year. Total the employment tax liability you reported inside it. At 50,000 dollars or less you are a monthly depositor for the current year. Above that, semiweekly. A brand new employer with no lookback history starts out monthly.

Monthly is simple. Everything withheld and owed during a calendar month is deposited by the 15th of the month after.

Semiweekly is keyed to the payday rather than the month. Pay on a Wednesday, Thursday or Friday and the deposit is due the following Wednesday. Pay Saturday through Tuesday and it is due that Friday. Holidays push the dates.

Sitting above both is the next day rule. Accumulate 100,000 dollars or more of employment tax liability on any single day and it is due by the next business day. A monthly depositor who trips it becomes semiweekly on the spot, for the balance of the year and all of the following one. Bonus runs and commission runs are where a small employer usually meets this rule for the first time.

Deposits are not returns, and returns have their own dates

A deposit moves money. A return reports it. Missing either is its own penalty.

Federal deposits move through the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System. Even where a payroll provider handles everything, enroll yourself and look at the account. Watching the deposits post is the only way to know the money arrived.

What late actually costs

The failure to deposit penalty is set by statute and it steps up with time. Section 6656 runs 2 percent for deposits one to five days late, 5 percent at six to fifteen days, 10 percent beyond that, and 15 percent on amounts still unpaid ten days after the IRS sends its first notice. Interest runs alongside. Filing the return late is a separate penalty on top.

A single run, priced honestly

Take a pay run of 20,000 dollars in gross wages, everybody still under the Social Security wage base for the year.

You withhold 1,240 dollars for Social Security and 290 dollars for Medicare, so 1,530 comes out of their pay before a cent of income tax withholding. Then you owe a matching 1,240 and 290 from your own funds, another 1,530. That one run generates 3,060 dollars of FICA, and only half of it was ever visible to the people you paid.

Now add the federal income tax you withheld, which depends on each W-4. Add FUTA on whatever part of those wages still sits under the annual per worker cap. Add state unemployment at your experience rate. Add workers compensation premium, which is also assessed on payroll. The gross number on the pay run is not the cost of the pay run, and the gap is wide enough that pricing a job off gross wages will lose you money on every hour worked.

The withheld pile deserves one last sentence. That money belonged to your employee, came out of their pay, and sits with you only until you hand it over. Spending it to cover a slow month is the most expensive decision available to a small employer, and the reason has very little to do with the deposit penalty.

Common questions

how often do I have to deposit federal payroll taxes

You are either a monthly or a semiweekly depositor, and the IRS assigns it from a lookback window of the four quarters ending June 30 of the prior year. Monthly depositors pay by the 15th of the following month. Semiweekly depositors pay on a schedule keyed to the payday itself, and any single day where liability reaches 100,000 dollars triggers a next business day deposit regardless of which group you were in.

what is the difference between a payroll tax deposit and a 941

The deposit moves the money and the Form 941 reports what the money was for. They run on different calendars, the deposit during the quarter and the return after it closes. Doing one and skipping the other produces its own penalty, so being current on deposits does not excuse a missing return.

why is my FUTA rate only 0.6 percent when the law says 6 percent

FUTA is imposed at 6.0 percent on the first 7,000 dollars of each worker's annual wages, then reduced by a credit of up to 5.4 percent for state unemployment tax paid on time. Paying the state late shrinks that credit. Operating in a state that owes the federal unemployment account money can shrink it for every employer in the state at once.

More on this