HIRING PAPERWORK
Offer Letter or Employment Agreement: What You Just Signed
An offer letter confirms terms and an employment agreement creates rights, and the sentence that decides which one you sent is usually the pay line.
You typed an offer letter, they signed it, and now somebody has asked whether that was a contract. It might have been. The answer turns on a handful of sentences most downloaded templates leave out, and on one line almost everybody writes the wrong way.
Start from the default. In nearly every state, employment is at will: either side can end it at any time, for any lawful reason, with or without notice. Montana stands as the known exception, where a statute limits discharge without good cause once an employee finishes a probationary period. Everywhere else, at will is what you have unless something you wrote changed it. An offer letter is supposed to confirm terms without disturbing that default. An employment agreement is supposed to change it on purpose, in exchange for something.
What belongs in an offer letter
Short is the point. A letter running three pages has stopped being a letter.
- The job title, and who the person reports to.
- The start date.
- The pay, stated as a rate per pay period or per hour.
- Whether the role is exempt or nonexempt under the Fair Labor Standards Act, and for a nonexempt role, that overtime is paid as the law requires.
- Benefits described as eligibility subject to the terms of the plans, never as a promise of any particular benefit.
- The contingencies, meaning completion of Form I-9, any lawful background check, and signature on your confidentiality agreement.
- A statement that employment is at will.
- A statement that the letter replaces prior discussions and that only a written document signed by an officer can change the at will relationship.
The salary sentence that writes a one year contract
Saying that an annual salary will be 72,000 dollars states a yearly figure, and courts in some places have read a yearly figure as implying a yearly term. That reading converts an at will letter into a fixed term agreement nobody meant to sign, and it surfaces exactly when you want to end the relationship in month four.
Write the rate instead. 6,000 dollars a month, paid semimonthly. Or 2,769.23 dollars per biweekly pay period. Same money, no implied term. Add a line saying pay is subject to applicable withholding and to change on notice going forward, and most of the argument disappears.
The same trap hides in words people use casually. A permanent position. A career opportunity here. As long as you keep performing. Every one of those has been argued as a promise. So has a handbook listing disciplinary steps as things the company will do rather than things it may do, which is why handbooks carry a disclaimer, and why the disclaimer needs to sit near the discipline section instead of only on page two.
When you actually want an agreement
An employment agreement is the right instrument where you are deliberately giving something up, or asking the employee to.
- A defined term, where both sides want the relationship fixed for a period.
- Severance, which is a promise to pay after the job ends and has to be written down to exist at all.
- A bonus or equity grant the person is relying on, where the mechanics need to be exact.
- Restrictive covenants worth negotiating, which usually means real customer or technical access.
- A senior hire leaving a stable job, who will not move without downside protection.
What the agreement mostly adds is structure around the ending.
Termination is the heart of it. For cause needs a definition narrow enough that the employee will sign it and broad enough that you can use it, usually with a cure period for the curable items. Without cause needs a notice period or pay in lieu of notice. Resignation for good reason lets the employee leave with severance when you materially change the deal, which is the clause protecting them from being demoted into quitting. Death and disability get their own lines, because they are neither resignations nor cause.
Bonus mechanics deserve more care than they usually get. Say whether the bonus is earned across the performance period or on the payment date, and say what happens to somebody who leaves partway through. Silence there produces a wage claim in some states and a windfall in others.
Then the protective pieces: confidentiality, assignment of inventions with the state required carve out for work an employee develops entirely on their own time and equipment, nonsolicitation of customers and staff, and a noncompete where one is lawful and proportionate.
Noncompetes are a state question, and it keeps moving
Enforceability is decided under state law, and the states disagree sharply. Several ban them outright for most workers. Others permit them only above a wage threshold, or only for defined categories, or only where you keep paying during the restricted period. Courts in many states will narrow an overbroad clause rather than enforce it as written. Courts elsewhere will strike the whole thing.
A federal rule that would have banned most noncompetes was issued and then set aside in court before it took effect, so state law still governs. Anybody telling you noncompetes are illegal nationwide is reading a headline rather than a docket.
For most small employers the practical answer is narrower anyway. A nonsolicitation clause covering the customers the person actually served, plus a confidentiality clause protecting information that is genuinely confidential, survives far more often than a broad noncompete and covers most of what you were worried about. A noncompete a court voids protects nothing whatsoever.
The paperwork around the paperwork
Several states require a separate written wage notice at hire, stating the rate, the regular pay day, the employer's legal name and contact details, and sometimes requiring a fresh notice when the rate changes. That notice is a statutory form. It is not your offer letter, and handing somebody the offer letter doesn't satisfy it.
If you use an arbitration agreement, keep it as its own document with its own signature, and know its limit. Federal law now lets an employee take a sexual assault or sexual harassment claim to court regardless of an arbitration clause they signed in advance. A clause claiming otherwise is unenforceable on that point, and it makes the rest of your paperwork look careless.
A few mechanical habits close the remaining gaps. Put an expiration date on the offer so it does not sit open for a month. Collect a countersignature and file it, rather than leaving it in an inbox. Check that the title and reporting line in the letter match what the person will actually do. And never set a start date you cannot support with a completed Form I-9 inside the first three business days.
One rescission point, because it catches people. If you extend an offer, the candidate resigns from a job in reliance on it, and you then pull the offer, some states will let that person recover what the reliance cost them even with no contract in place. Withdraw an offer in writing, for a stated reason, as early as you possibly can.
Match the instrument to the risk. A part time counter hire does not need an employment agreement. The person who will hold your customer list, your pricing and your keys should not be starting on a two line letter you found on the internet.
Common questions
is an offer letter a legally binding contract
It can turn into one, which is the trouble with treating it as a formality. A letter that states an annual salary, promises a permanent position, or leaves out an at will statement has been read as creating contractual rights in more than one state. Write the pay as a rate per pay period, say plainly that employment is at will, and state that only a signed document from an officer changes that.
what is the difference between an offer letter and an employment agreement
An offer letter confirms the terms of an at will job without disturbing the default that either side can end it whenever they choose. An employment agreement trades that default away, usually for a defined term, defined termination rights, severance, or restrictive covenants. The agreement buys you control over how the job ends and costs you the ability to simply stop.
can I still use a noncompete for my employees
That depends entirely on your state, because several ban them for most workers while others permit them above a wage threshold or inside defined categories. A federal rule aimed at banning most of them was set aside in court before it ever took effect, so state law still decides the question. For a lot of small employers, a customer nonsolicitation clause paired with a real confidentiality clause protects more and holds up better.