Payroll and People Paying a team without creating a liability.

Payroll and People

HIRING COMPLIANCE

Form I-9 and E-Verify, in Practical Terms

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

Every new hire needs a Form I-9 inside three business days, and E-Verify is a separate system with its own rules about who runs it and when.

Somebody starts Monday. What actually has to happen about the Form I-9, and does any of it involve E-Verify?

Two separate systems, with two separate answers. The I-9 is required of every employer for every person hired to work in the United States, with no exemption for small businesses and none for citizens. E-Verify is a separate electronic check, voluntary under federal law for most employers and mandatory where a federal contract clause or a state statute says so. Running E-Verify does not replace the I-9. Nothing replaces the I-9.

The timeline is tighter than people think

Section 1 belongs to the employee. They complete and sign it no later than their first day of employment. They may do it after accepting the offer and before the start date. They may never do it before an offer has been accepted.

Section 2 belongs to you. You examine the employee's documents and complete Section 2 within three business days of the first day of work for pay. Where the job itself runs shorter than three days, Section 2 has to be finished on that first day.

That clock doesn't pause for a busy week. It does not pause because the person works remotely, and it does not pause while you wait on a background check.

Documents: theirs to choose, yours to examine

The form carries three lists. A document from List A establishes identity and work authorization together. A document from List B establishes identity alone. A document from List C establishes work authorization alone. The employee presents one document from List A, or one from List B paired with one from List C.

The choice belongs to the employee. You may hand over the list of acceptable documents. You may not tell them which to bring, you may not ask for a particular card by name, and you may not ask for extra documents because something about the person made you curious. Each of those is its own violation, enforced by the Immigrant and Employee Rights section at the Department of Justice, and it stands entirely apart from anything about the form.

Your standard for examining is reasonableness. The document must be unexpired, must reasonably appear genuine, and must reasonably appear to relate to the person handing it over. You are not a forensic document examiner and the law does not ask you to become one. It asks you to look at an original.

In person is the default. An alternative procedure permits examination over live video, available to employers enrolled in E-Verify and in good standing with it. Using it means keeping copies of the documents, holding a live interaction rather than watching a recording, and applying the procedure consistently across a defined group instead of person by person. Employers outside E-Verify examine originals physically, remote hires included, which usually means an authorized representative meeting the person locally.

Keeping, correcting and purging

Store I-9s apart from personnel files. One binder, or one section of your system, holding nothing else. The reason is practical. When an inspection arrives you hand over I-9s and nothing but I-9s, and a form living inside a personnel file means handing over the personnel file.

Retention runs on a two part rule. Keep each form for three years after the date of hire, or one year after employment ends, whichever falls later. Work that date out at every departure and calendar the purge, because holding forms past their period only gives an inspection more paper to find errors in.

Correcting an error is allowed and expected. Draw a single line through the wrong entry, write the correct entry beside it, then initial and date what you did. Never erase, never white out, and never write a date earlier than the day you actually made the change. Where a section is too tangled to repair, complete a fresh form, attach it to the original, and add a short memo explaining. The original stays. Destroying it turns a paperwork problem into a different kind of problem.

Reverification uses Supplement B, and the rule about what you may reverify matters more than the mechanics of it. Reverify when a temporary work authorization expires. Do not reverify a United States passport. Do not reverify a Permanent Resident Card, even at its printed expiration. Do not reverify List B identity documents at all. Reverifying something you had no business reverifying is itself a discrimination issue.

Self audits repay the effort and are easy to do badly. Audit the whole workforce, or a genuinely neutral slice of it, never a group picked out by name, accent or national origin. Fix what is fixable. A technical error corrected before an inspection is usually nothing at all. The same error found by an inspector becomes a line on a penalty calculation.

And the reason all of that runs on a clock: a Notice of Inspection from Immigration and Customs Enforcement gives you three business days to produce the forms. Three days is not enough time to build a file. It is barely enough time to copy one.

E-Verify, and the rules that arrive with it

E-Verify compares what the employee wrote on the I-9 against records held by the Department of Homeland Security and the Social Security Administration. Enrolling means signing a memorandum of understanding, and the memorandum is where your obligations actually live.

A case comes back either authorized or as a mismatch, the status formerly called a tentative nonconfirmation. A mismatch is not a finding that somebody lacks authorization. It means the records failed to line up, and the causes include name changes, data entry errors and an agency record nobody ever updated.

What happens next is scripted, and the script is the whole point. Notify the employee privately. Give them the notice the system generates. If they choose to contest, refer the case and let the process run its course. While a case is pending you may not fire, suspend, withhold pay, delay a start date, cut hours or hold back training. Treating a mismatch as a verdict is the most common way an employer converts a records problem into a lawsuit.

A final nonconfirmation permits termination. Keep the person anyway and the system requires you to say so. Either way, the decision gets recorded.

Building it so it runs without you

Four things turn this from a recurring scramble into a process that works.

Name one person who owns it, with a named backup for vacations. Move Section 1 into your offer acceptance flow so it is finished before day one rather than during it. Keep a tickler for every expiring work authorization, dated well ahead of the expiration instead of on it. Calendar the purge dates the same way you calendar the retention.

None of that is hard. It is the kind of work that never feels urgent until three business days after a letter arrives.

Common questions

how long do I have to complete a new hire's I-9

The employee completes Section 1 no later than their first day of employment. You complete Section 2 within three business days of that first day of work for pay, and where the job itself runs shorter than three days, Section 2 has to be done on the first day. That clock does not pause for a background check or for a remote start.

do I have to use E-Verify for my employees

Only where a federal contract clause or your state law requires it, since E-Verify is voluntary under federal law for most employers. The Form I-9 is required either way, and running E-Verify never replaces it. Once you enroll, you have to run every new hire at that site instead of picking and choosing.

can I fire someone who gets a tentative nonconfirmation from E-Verify

No. A mismatch, which is what that status is now called, means the records failed to line up, and the usual causes are name changes and data errors rather than anything about the person's authorization. While the case is being contested you cannot terminate, suspend, cut hours, withhold pay or delay training, and doing any of it is a separate violation.

More on this